I LOVEE the girl so much and they have SOO much talent, potential, everything. Their performances are fire, their vocals eat, they're gorgeous and are getting SO much attention and opportunities (Lollapalooza, GAP advertisements, etc..), yet HYBE keep playing games with them. There are a couple big problems with the group that spiral into thousand little ones: Their music quality: I'm sorry to say it, but KATSEYE'S music sucks. Yes, they try 'different' things (especially w/ gnarly), but they're not exactly good things. Gnarly got SO much criticism at the beginning, and even though now it's calmed down and people think it's 'iconic', it's just going to come back to bite them. Gnarly went mega viral, but not for the right reasons. The lyricism was cringy and trash, the concept was good, but some ppl thought it was inappropriate, especially since they had a minor in the group, and the dance, even though it went viral later on, received backlash for its twerking moves (again, bc Yoonchae was a minor). Imo, the choreography was fire. Energetic, sharp, fit the whole intrumental of the song. The concept was weird, but cool, though some scenes were definitely questionable. The beat was really out of place sometimes, and they added some weird sound effects (the moans, slashing sounds) that sounded so weird all put together. And the lyricism was trash. OMD I was so disappointed with the whole song, it was everywhere at once, the lyrics were straight-up horrible, there was barely any promo.. it was SOO messy. On top of that, their music is NOT serious at all. Gnarly was such a silly song, with its horrible lyricism and weirder concept, and Touch, Debut and both their EPs don't give off 'serious music career', they give off 'trend-hopping'. Like, Touch was what worked at the time, and it wasn't even a relatively good song, it was just an easy listen. Then Gnarly came, and that was even worse. Their music is so unserious, and while HYBE and their fans are trying to paint them as 'artists', their music paints them as trend-hopping k-pop idols. Nothing special, but mediocre enough to get into the charts. And this is further proved by the fact that their first EP, SIS (Soft Is Strong) barely made ANY noise whatsoever. The songs were just easy listens, but they didn't have any substance, so it barely made any noise and just kind of disappeared. Also, the fact that their music seems so unoriginally uninspired. Like, take other groups like ILLIT, LESSERAFIM and NewJeans. Maybe their songs (though ALL of these groups, esp NewJeans music, LESSERAFIM's HOT and UNFORGIVEN album and ILLIT'S bomb are incredibly good music) don't give off 'serious music career' they're GREAT songs. The songs have good lyricism, great beats, a good concept, but most importantly, the members themselves take part in the writing of the song. Danielle, for example wrote the most songs out of all of her members, Yunah helped write Do the dance, and we all know that Yunjin helps to write and produce her own solo music. So while it may not give off 'serious music career', it comes off as more honest and has more substance bc the members at least took part in writing it. Another problem with their music is that it's so inconsistent. Like, we had Debut, then, we had Touch. The releases didn't make sense bc they were so different to each other. They started with this strong, performing, empowering concept and music style with debt (kind of like girl crush in K-pop, I think?), then suddenly did a 180 and released Touch. And the problem was that even though Touch went viral, it was nothing new or fresh. Pretty much everybody in the company was doing a cuter concept. ILLIT's sweeter, cute concept w/ Magnetic and I'll like you, ENHYPEN'S romance: untold album, which was a cuter, sweeter direction in their music, NewJeans w/ Right Now. It was nothing that stood out, because it was so mediocre. ESPECIALLY since ALL the other releases were SO good. ENHYPEN's album was amazing, ILLIT's music was so good, and their concept ate, and NewJeans' music and concept is always bomb. Like, Touch didn't even stand out, and it wasn't as good as the other releases. Then, after Touch, again a full 180 and BAM: Gnarly. Gnarly felt so rushed and out of place compared to their other releases, especially Touch that it was insane. Like, we had NO time to prepare or to adjust to receive this change in their music, style and visuals. It was so stupid, too, bc there was barely any promo and the song was not good. ENHYPEN transitioned from Romance:Untold to Desire:Unleash so good bc they had smth in the middle: Their Romance:Untold daydream version, which contained Daydream and No doubt. Daydream was a much sexier, stronger song than the rest of the album, preparing us for Desire:Unleash, while No doubt was a more pop song that still fit with Romance:Untold, so the transition wasn't exactly unexpected, and it was done so well. KATSEYE's just seemed rushed and quickly strewn in. 2) Their concept: The problem with this is that they have NO concept. No interesting storyline in ANY of their songs as well, and when you realise that groups like ENHYPEN are there too, whose concept is so beautifully written, produced and executed by both the workers and the members themselves, you realise KATSEYE really lacks in that. ENHYPEN's concept is SOO good, it's always interesting, beautiful and evolves and grows with the members, their music and their styles; NewJeans concept is so fresh and also shares a storyline in some M/Vs (OMG, Ditto, Get Up and Cool with You, ETA etc..); same with ILLIT, they do like a cute-creepy concept in some way and it is interesting and gorgeous every time. When you compare these groups' amazing storylines and concepts with KATSEYE's, which has none, you get less interested in their M/Vs and concept than you would if they had an actual storyline/concept that could evolve and grow with them. 3) The members' relationships and how their fans react: I'm not gonna pretend to know everything about their friendships at all, bc we only see what is in the camera; however, a lot of assumptions come from moments in Dream Academy, and sets me clear on who watched it or not by the following point: -Manon was bullied and excluded: No, she was not. She herself siad that living with girls was 'too much' and 'dramatic' for her, bc she hadn't done that before. However, NONE of them had, but they all sucked it up except Manon. She broke the curfew rules several times, and while others were warned, she got to leave happily and live with her aunt. Of course, while all the girls lived together, she would miss things, but that was her OWN choice to not live with them. Obviously, she would miss things bc she wasn't living with them, but that was not any of the other girls' faults at all. And Manon skipped so much practice. Yes, sometimes bc she was sick, but so many other bc she didn't want to come. And she didn't bother to keep in touch with the others to learn the dance. She showed up randomly. And the other girls and even the senior program manager, Missy, expressed concern for Manon's work ethic. -Daniela and Naisha hanging out: There's no problem with her hanging out w/ a former girl from Dream Academy, except that Naisha made comments about brown girls that excluded Manon. E.g: she made a comment on Lara's Instagram post about 'holding down the spot for all brown girls' when Manon was literally also in the group. It was weird of Dani to hang out with her, but ofc that's her own choice. However, fans also have to hold her accountable; if she's gonna hang out with someone who blatantly disrespected Manon, then her fans and Manon both have a right to feel a little offended. As well as the fact that people are SO obsessed with pitting BLACKPINK and KATSEYE against each other. BLACKPINK aren't lazy, they're inconsistent, which ofc ppl have a right to be mad abt, but BLACKPINK'S rookie era was even better than KATSEYE, and their music is better. Using KATSEYE to try to disrespect Jennie makes no sense. Yes, she's inconsistent with her performances, but she can definitely have amazing, show-stopping ones (Coachella 2019, 2023, and 2025, her Deadline Tour performances, especially her solo ones, her 2018 SOLO performance at mama etc). Like, why do you feel the need to include other women who have fought so hard as well for where they're at right now to uplift yours? It's so immature how some fans genuinely cannot uplift their group without bashing others. HYBE needs to stop playing around with KATSEYE, and give them the music, promo, budget and concept these girls deserve after all their hard work and talent. They have such a good group in their hands, and they keep messing up bc fans keep settling for the bare minimum in music quality, concepts and M/Vs. I know damn well these girls can hit high notes perfectly fine and would fit so many good, serious music concepts, so HYBE needs to GET UPP. submitted by /u/positions-deluxe [link] [comments]