This might be a REALLY unpopular opinion, but I don't think KATSEYE'S music is really good; don't get me wrong, this is NOT a diss at the girl's talent, bc I find it so surprising every time they give us great performances with the music quality they have. But generally, I feel like SOME of their fans are trying to paint them as artists when their music is anything but serious is funny to me. Their music doesn't come off as honest, sincere or genuine; it comes off as a trend. Like, ppl want us to believe they're a global group, but it seems to me like they're just like a K-pop group. When I think of global groups, I think One Direction, Little Mix, Spice Girls, Fifth Harmony etc... these groups gave great performances and had great voices like KATSEYE, but their music DID give off serious career vibes. It wasn't about fitting a standard just for their fans to claim it didn't, and they bent different genres and had sentimental, sincere songs as well as upbeat pop-ish ones. Also, that the members took part in the songwriting/producing. When you put into perspective that the same company that debuted KATSEYE debuted LESSERAFIM, ILLIT, ENHYPEN and NewJeans... Apart from ENHYPEN, and at times LESSERAFIM, the other two groups don't exactly give off 'serious career' I'll admit, but their songs are REALLY good, and the concept EATS every time. As well as the members taking a part in writing the songs themselves. E.g. Danielle wrote the most songs out of NewJeans, so even if the songs weren't exactly 'serious', they came off as more sincere bc the members took a part in writing them. And the concept...it was SOO good. Especially with Ditto, it was such a good song with such an honest, sentimental message. Another example is Yunah helping to write Do the Dance. I'm aware she wrote like one or two lines, but it still gives the impression that at least she's thinking about helping in the process of her and her group's music. And again, their concept eats. And ENHYPEN, my god, their storyline and concept is sooo superior. We get so many different things from them that somehow all add up, which is what I want to see from KATSEYE. It seemed like from Debut, to Touch, to then Gnarly, and finally Gabriela, everything has been so rushed. Like, each release was so inconsistent and sudden. We had cute Touch in a universe where all the other groups were shooting cuter, sweeter concepts (NewJeans Right Now, ENHYPEN Romance: Untold, ILLIT Magnetic, and I'LL LIKE YOU), then did a full 180 to Gnarly. With barely any promo, so it was a big shock and came off as kind of rushed. For example, ENHYPEN's move from Romance: Untold to Desire: Unleash was smoother bc they shot a deluxe version of Romance: Untold that allowed us to ease into the darker, sexier concept of Desire: Unleash. Also, the fact that Jay took part in the writing and producing of Helium, so it came off as more honest. Ofc, I get it if KATSEYE don't need a concept, but they should release more serious music. Like, having Lara and Manon rapping 'gang' for a literal verse and calling it a day was crazy. I want these girls to blow up even more than they have, explore serious genres and build a career that could potentially win them SOO many awards, but for that, they need good music and concepts. For now, Gnarly was all over the place, and the lyricism...well. Touch, like I said, sounded like a song made to fit a trend. Not good, but kind of bland. SIS was kind of a hit and miss; Gabriela ATE DOWNNN, but the rest of the EP seemed like it was kind of empty. Gameboy and Touch kinda gave me the same vibes, and Mean Girls was more honest and sentimental, but it wasn't promoted enough. MIA seemed kind of out of place, IMO. I hope HYBE or them decide to give them better music in the future, prepping for a real, genuine career, bc with the talent, beauty and passion these girls have, they could easily become the next top band. It just pisses me off to have so much talent and potential wasted on music as hollow as that. THIS IS JUST MY OPINION, EVERYBODY'S FREE TO SHARE THEIRS!! submitted by /u/positions-deluxe [link] [comments]